Short answer: NMJL scoring decides who pays how much for a winning hand (card value × discard / self-pick / jokerless). A pie (also called PY / “purse is empty”) is a table stake limit some clubs use — it is not a required League rule. Agree pie amount, chips vs cash, and what happens when a purse is empty before the first deal. Prefer chips or a ledger when cash play is inappropriate; follow local law.
Scoring answers: “How many points is this hand, and who pays whom under League payment math?” That lives on scoring.
Pie / table stakes answer: “How much cash or chips does each player risk tonight, and what happens when someone’s purse is empty?” That is table culture. It is not an NMJL requirement. Agree it out loud before the first deal.
Keep League math and stake customs in separate columns.
| Topic | League default (scoring) | Pie / PY (table custom) | Chips / ledger |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it decides | Multipliers from the card value (discard vs self-pick, jokerless, etc.) | How much each player can lose in a session; behavior when “purse is empty” | How you track the same payments without loose cash |
| Is it NMJL-required? | Yes — payment math is League scoring | No — optional house stake limit | No — bookkeeping choice |
| When purse is empty | N/A (scores assume all three others pay) | Common custom: player keeps playing but stops paying until they win some back — exact rules vary | Usually still track full amounts; settle at end |
| Fairness note | Everyone who owes pays the published multiples | League historically warned PY can be unfair to early winners who cannot collect from empty purses | League-style suggestion often cited: extra chips, settle at usual stakes |
| Where to read more | Scoring | This page + your club’s spoken agreement | Same as scoring; medium is chips/paper |
Say these aloud at a new table. Write them in a group chat if the club is large.
| Agree on… | Example prompt |
|---|---|
| Point value in money or chips | “Is the card value in cents, nickels, or chip units?” |
| Pie / PY amount (if any) | “Are we each bringing a fixed pie? How much?” |
| What happens when pie is gone | “Do empty-pie players stop paying? Can they still collect when they win?” |
| Cash vs chips vs paper | “Chips on the table; settle in the parking lot / Venmo later?” |
| Doubling house rules (if any) | “Dice doubles = double this hand only?” (not League default) |
| Hot / cold wall | Separate from pie — see wall game |
| Fifth player / bettor (if any) | “Sit-out only, or bettor too?” — details on 5 / 6 players |
| Dispute process | “Card + NMJL booklet first; house list second.” |
A fifth (or sixth) person usually sits out and rotates in after East; they may optionally act as a bettor after the Charleston. Full rotation tables, silence red lines, and settlement → American Mahjong with 5 or 6 players. Agree stakes on this page’s checklist; do not assume four-player scoring covers the bettor automatically.
A pie (often called PY by the League; players also say “purse is empty”) is a table stake limit: each player brings a fixed amount and, once it is gone, keeps playing but stops paying until they win money back — exact logistics vary by group.
No. Pie/PY is a house (table) custom about stakes, not a required League scoring rule. League default scoring is who pays how much for a winning hand — see the scoring page.
In a historical bulletin, the League described PY as potentially unfair to early winners (they may not collect from players who are out of pie, yet may still have to pay those players later). A common League suggestion: start with extra chips and settle at usual stakes. Confirm current published wording; do not treat this page as a bulletin reprint.
Agree before the first deal. Many groups use chips or paper ledgers in public and settle later. Local law and venue rules always come first — this site does not encourage illegal gambling.
Hot/cold wall change how the last wall plays. Pie/stakes change how money or chips move when someone wins. Separate agreements — see wall game for hot/cold.
Optional. Four still play; the fifth sits out (and may bet after the Charleston). Rotation, silence rules, and settlement → 5 or 6 players. Agree stakes here; it is not required by League four-player scoring.
Beginner hub: how to play · FAQ.
Pie/PY is table culture; League scoring is separate. Cross-check public Q&A — do not treat club blogs as official law.