Short answer: Yes. American Mah Jongg is still a four-player game. With five or six people, four sit and play; the extras sit out and rotate in after each hand (East steps away; a sit-out takes that seat). Many groups also use an optional bettor: after the Charleston, the sit-out privately picks who they think will win, records it face-down, stays silent, and settles the same way as the player they backed. This page summarizes those procedures from secondary sources that cite the League rulebook — confirm against your copy of Mah Jongg Made Easy.
The National Mah Jongg League’s rulebook, Mah Jongg Made Easy, covers five-handed play. Secondary write-ups that quote that book (and older editions) describe two complementary ideas:
The four seated players still use the current year’s NMJL card, the normal deal, the Charleston, and standard scoring. Fewer than four? See 3 players and 2 players.
Four play; one sits. After each hand, East leaves and the sit-out sits.
| # | Step | Source label |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | All five roll the dice. The lowest roll sits out first (ties re-roll) | As summarized — Sloper FAQ 13A citing NMJL rulebook 2018; AMA guide matches |
| 2 | The other four play a normal hand (deal, Charleston, play, score) | Same as four-player game |
| 3 | When the hand ends and payments finish, East steps away from the table | As summarized — Sloper FAQ 13A; Mahj Life Art. 150 (MJME 2024) |
| 4 | The sit-out takes East’s seat and becomes a seated player for the next hand | As summarized — same sources |
| 5 | Former East is now the sit-out (and may be the bettor if you use that option) | As summarized — Mahj Life Art. 150 |
| 6 | Repeat after every hand so each person sits out in turn | Same pattern |
With six people, two sit out while four play. As summarized by Tom Sloper’s FAQ 13A (citing the Official NMJL rulebook, 2018, pp. 24–26): when the previous dealer gets up, one of the sit-outs sits in; when the next dealer gets up, the other sit-out sits in. Keep the rotation orderly so both extras take turns fairly.
| Moment | What happens | Label |
|---|---|---|
| Start | All six roll; the two lowest sit out first (re-roll ties) | As summarized — AMA guide; same dice idea as five-player |
| End of a hand | East steps away; next sit-out in line takes that seat | As summarized — Sloper FAQ 13A citing NMJL 2018 |
| Next hand end | New East steps away; the remaining sit-out (or next in queue) enters | As summarized — Sloper FAQ 13A |
| Fairness check | Track sits so nobody sits out two hands more than anyone else over a session | House rule — session bookkeeping; AMA says “ensure each sits out equally” |
If both sit-outs also bet (common at six-player tables), each records a private choice independently — see the bettor section below. Discussing bets with each other voids the spirit of the rule; treat that as interference.
A bettor is the player sitting out who optionally backs a seated hand. As summarized by Mahj Life, Article 150 (citing Mah Jongg Made Easy, 2024, p. 25) and by Sloper FAQ 13A:
Same money path as the player you backed — with special wall-game notes.
| Outcome | What the bettor does | Source label |
|---|---|---|
| Bet-on player wins | Bettor collects the same as that winner (including the usual self-pick vs discard pattern that winner receives) | As summarized — Mahj Life Art. 150; Sloper FAQ 13A |
| Bet-on player loses (someone else wins) | Bettor pays the same as the bet-on player would pay the winner | As summarized — Mahj Life Art. 150; Sloper FAQ 13A |
| Correct wall-game bet (no one mahjongs) | Bettor receives the lowest value on the current card from the seated players | As summarized — Mahj Life Art. 150 (MJME 2024) |
| Wrong wall-game bet (someone wins) | Bettor pays the winner the same as a losing, non-discarding player | As summarized — Mahj Life Art. 150 |
| Bettor interferes or talks about the hand / the bet | Bet is cancelled; no collect, no pay from that bet | As summarized — Mahj Life Art. 123 / 150 |
| Whether the bettor is bound by pie / PY limits | Not covered in the passages we could verify | House rule — add to your pie checklist |
| Exact chip vs cash logistics, tip jars, betting wheels as products | Table / club choice — not required to play | House rule |
Base amounts still come from the card and the usual who-pays rules — see scoring and wall game. After settlement, rotate seats as in the tables above.
| Topic | Covered in secondary League citations | House / table decision |
|---|---|---|
| Four play; extras sit out and rotate after East | Yes — Sloper (NMJL 2018); Mahj Life Art. 150 (MJME 2024) | Exact seating chart on paper |
| Optional bettor after Charleston; silent; same settle as bet-on | Yes — Mahj Life Art. 123 / 150; Sloper FAQ 13A | Whether you use a bettor at all |
| Wall-game bet pays lowest card value | Yes — Mahj Life Art. 150 | — |
| Pie / PY applies to the bettor | Not verified here | House rule |
| Bettor may look at racks before choosing | Described by Sloper / Mahj Life / AMA as part of the method | How long they may look; no coaching |
| Using a commercial “bettor wheel” | Not required — paper works | House rule / optional gear |
| Five people all holding tiles (5-star / extra-tile variants) | Not League four-handed play | House rule — separate from this page |
Before-you-deal checklist (say it out loud once):
Yes. Four players sit and play a normal hand. The fifth sits out first (often the low dice roll), then rotates in: after each hand, East steps away and the sit-out takes that seat.
An optional role for the player sitting out. After the Charleston, the bettor privately picks which seated player (or a wall game) they think will win, records the choice face-down, and must stay silent about the hand or the bet is void.
As summarized from the League rulebook by secondary sources: the bettor collects the same as the bet-on player if that player wins, or pays the same as that player if they lose. Wall-game bets have their own settlement (table above).
Yes. Two players sit out while four play. After each hand, East steps away and one sit-out takes the seat; keep rotating so sits-outs are shared fairly.
No. Sit-out rotation alone is enough. The bettor is an optional League-described variation for five (and commonly six) players — agree whether you use it before the first deal.
No. The four seated players still use the current year’s NMJL card, Charleston, and scoring. Only who sits and whether someone bets change.
More beginner questions: FAQ · full overview: how to play American Mahjong.
Secondary sources that cite the League rulebook. We could not open the booklet pages ourselves; confirm against your copy of Mah Jongg Made Easy.